Positive Insights From the Emerging Church
I find that there is a sub-section of Christians, particularly reformed Christians, that love to blast the emerging church movement; but most of the time they don't even know the wide array of opinions on the issue and the benefits of it. I recently listened to a series of sermons where a reformed baptist pastor does acknowledge good things in his critique. The emerging movement is not above criticism from the Scriptures, but we must be sure to recognize positive contributions it has made.
Recognizing the Need For Postmodern Contextualization
The truth is that postmodernity brings with it new challenges to the church and her mission to spread the kingdom of God. Postmodernity, with its relativistic, skeptical epistemology challenges the very foundations of the absolute claims of the Christian faith. The emerging movement calls the church at large to recognize the difficulties present in this age of postmodernity, and the adherents strive hard to meet these people where they're at.
There are certainly people in the movement that take contextualization to far often by compromising core Biblical teachings, but we must not shy away from contextualization because some have done so irresponsibly. Jesus in John 4, Paul in Acts 17 and 1 Cor 9:20-21 are a few examples of the use of contextualization in the first century. It is not a new idea foreign to the great commission.
The Call For Missional Living
Christians all-to-often live in a world that really doesn't exist. We must remember that "the Word became flesh, and dwelt among us" (John 1:14). Jesus, the God-man, condescended from heaven to dwell amongst sinners. God comes to us'not us to him. We must remember this when we strive to live like Christ.
We must remember that our lives as missionaries is not reserved for a special outreach time, but it is a lifestyle, a joy, and a command from our Lord. Engaging the sick, poor, widowed, and postmodern people happens by living life next to them and showing them Christ in our words and actions. Jesus himself said, "Let your light shine before men in such a way that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father who is in heaven" (Mat 5:16). But we must remember that social action must not be the ends in and of itself, because we must ensure that the Gospel is the under-pinning and motivation for our actions.
Challenging the Clery/Laity Distinction
Christians often don't realize how Catholic ecclessiology continues to have a tremendous influence even in Protestant churches. The model of a sharp clergy/laity distinction finds its roots in Catholicism, and it was an error perpetuated by the reformers. The New Testament speaks of elders and deacons who are charged by God to teach, lead, and exemplify Godliness; but the idea of professional clergy is an aberrant concept to New Testament churches.
The Protestant Reformers as well as most Reformed churches today, have been unable to break with the strict clericalism which they have inherited from both Rome and Constantine. The Reformers were right in their soteriology (doctrine of salvation), but wrong in their ecclesiology (doctrine of the church). They rediscovered the Gospel, but were unable to fully recover the ecclesiology of the New Testament. Thus, in many respects, the Reformation was only a partial reformation. (Source)
Effectively Utilizing Technology
As a web designer I am in a special way appreciative of this last point. Members have found much success in influencing many, because they have seen the value in new technologies and democratization of information. Traditional church leaders often don't realize the incredible power that a strong web presence can have, and it is becoming a strategic way to reach those who otherwise would not be reached.
Conclusion
There are certainly things that trouble me about the emerging movement, but I feel it's important to outline contributions that the movement has made that the church at large should listen to. We must not shrug off something, because we see it as "new" especially when the ideas present within are as old as the Gospel itself. We must continue to remember that "we are no longer to be children, tossed here and there by waves and carried about by every wind of doctrine, by the trickery of men, by craftiness in deceitful scheming; but speaking the truth in love, we are to grow up in all aspects into Him who is the head, even Christ, from whom the whole body, being fitted and held together by what every joint supplies, according to the proper working of each individual part, causes the growth of the body for the building up of itself in love" (Eph 4:14-16).
Jun 22nd 2007
Good insights. We need a good dose of "semper reformanda" (always reforming) today. Too many reformed believers refuse to learn from anything newer than the WCF, which is quite in opposition to the spirit of those who wrote the WCF.
Jun 22nd 2007
@Nathan: I was actually thinking of that very phrasing today while drafting this post in my head. You would like that article I cite above.
Jun 22nd 2007
Good article. I have often been disapointed by the fact that so many people seem to willing to tear down the tenants of the Emerging Church/Movement without taking time to consider the validity of its points. I too have concerns about the Emerging Movement but I do feel they raise some legitimate concerns about the Church.
Jun 26th 2007
Chris, buddy, you gotta read "The Forgotten Ways" by Alan Hirsch. It's fantastic. Think Neil Cole's "Organic Church" but with more theology and a better documented set of cases. Not only that, but it really highlights the role of the modern day apostle/apostolically gifted individuals within the role of the New Testament church and the body as we see it. I'm a firm believer that house church and sweeping church movements that are very unhierarchial and untraditional will be the way of the west. It's just the nature of Christ to rebuild His bride with unconventional means, especially in our postmodern world of today.-Paul
Jul 18th 2007
I definitely hold the same position as you. I think what we're talking about here is how we have to avoid the extremes of conservative or emergent ideaologies. Would you agree?
Jul 27th 2007
@Ben: I wouldn't say that "conservative" is an extreme. I think you mean "fundamentalism" right? In that case then we would agree.
Jul 27th 2007
Yeah, you know what I mean ;).